Monday, January 26, 2009

It’s pretty interesting to think about Eddie Izzard’s performance that we watched last week. Here he was, an English man dressed as a woman poking fun at the American national anthem. It’s the type of thing that would seemingly tick off many, many Americans, yet Izzard pulls the trick off without ever sounding cruel, or even nasty. I think this is because he only jabs at the superficial elements of the song, making sure never to cross the line of decency. He makes us realize how ridiculous it is, how ridiculous we look, while managing to never seem completely out of line. This takes a deft touch from the comedian, something that few can ever really pull off.

Another reason why Izzard gets away with it so easily is how he prefaces the joke by first making fun of his own national anthem. This tactic essentially makes him invincible to any complaint, because he is making fun of himself first. And this is the thing that all great comedians are able to do – make fun of themselves. Look at how Mel Brooks makes fun of Jewish people, how Dennis Leary jabs at Catholics, and how Chris Rock ridicules black people. Doing this first allows the comedian to then step outside his own sphere and into others. By making himself vulnerable he makes himself able to attack, without fear of repercussion. It is why Eddie Izzard can make fun of transvestites and not sound mean in doing so. When the comedian presents himself, “Hey, I’m just like you,” he permits himself to say pretty much whatever he likes. And in doing so, he arms himself with his most effective weapon – criticism of hypocrisy.

2 comments:

  1. Hi, Kevin,

    I agree with your comments about Izzard's persona being a "I'm making fun of myself, too" move. I just posted a similar comment on Greg's blog.

    But your post got me thinking about something else. Regarding that specific national anthem joke, I think the reason it worked for me was that it gave me a chance to laugh at people I think are idiots. In other words, people not like me (or so I like to think, right?). I think the anthem joke is funnier to me because of the ignorant patriotism I see (what some might call a "red state mentality") that seems more prevalent since 9/11. For some reason (probably because of the superiority theory), I really like jokes that poke fun at passionate patriots. I guess I think that if these passionate patriots paid attention to what really goes on in our country, they couldn't possibly be so proud to be American. I don't know if my view makes me more or less American. That's a discussion for a poli-sci class, I suppose.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Two questions arise from your post here --one is the question that you bring up when you talk about "not crossing the line of decency"--where exactly is that in terms of the national anthem? The other is the fact that much of what we now consider "American" is borrowed from the Brits (tho according to Izzard, definitely not a sense of history)perhaps we are laughing at ourselves in this superior fashion because we feel like we can now that we are separate. Is there anything about Izzard's portrayal that is "universal?"

    ReplyDelete